Why Most Brands Get ROI Wrong

Most brands judge influencer campaigns by follower count. A creator with 100K followers isn't automatically worth more than one with 10K. What matters is CPM, CPC, and engagement rate — the same metrics you'd use to evaluate any paid media campaign.

The Metrics That Actually Matter

These are the numbers you need to track for every influencer activation:

Real Data from Our Campaigns

Here's what our influencer campaigns actually delivered:

$24.55
X Shadyside C1 CPM
$1.00
X Shadyside C1 CPC
$30.81
X Shadyside C2 CPM
$2.29
X Shadyside C2 CPC
$4
Dr. Tea CPM
$2
Dr. Tea CPC

Industry average CPM sits at $20–$50, with CPC varying widely by niche. Across 15+ creator activations, The Stoop consistently delivers CPMs between $4–$31 — well below the industry average of $20–$50.

How to Calculate Your Own

When Influencer Marketing Makes Sense

Influencer marketing works best for local businesses, product launches, seasonal campaigns, and brand awareness plays. When it doesn't make sense: no tracking in place, no clear goal, or wrong audience fit. If you can't measure it, you can't improve it — and you definitely can't prove ROI.

Ready to get started with influencer marketing? See our results or explore our services.

View X Shadyside Influencer Marketing